Student Book Review:

by: Mary Stewart
Review done by:

Ben Hemmendinger
Grade 7
Van Antwerp Middle School
Niskayuna, NY

This exciting classic is the second book in the Merlin Trilogy: one of the most thorough versions of the Arthurian Legends, as seen through the eyes of Merlin. This series tries to explain the mysteries of Merlin's life, to make his magic seem like a matter of religion and belief rather than newt's noses and big black pots. I think that it has some insights as well as adventure, and while there is plenty of gore and guts and battle, this book would be better suited to thinkers.
The Trilogy began with Merlin as a little boy in The Crystal Cave, who is now a grown man and prestigious advisor to the high king. One would probably have to read The Crystal Cave to understand what is going on. Merlin is, in the Trilogy, a talented doctor, scientist, architect, and politician-about everything except a wizard. The story contradicts many things one might know about the High King's wizard. For instance, Merlin happens to be Arthur's Uncle. In The Hollow Hills, Merlin raises Arthur and brings him to reign on the high throne. He has to keep Arthur safe and away from the enemies of his father, Uther, to whom Arthur remains unacknowledged, and eventually has to prove him to Uther. Some intrigue gets involved, which I'd really like to explain, but you should read it for yourself to see what happens.
These books are really a great series to read for those who have read other versions of the Arthurian Legends, or like the Middle Ages. They are not in the traditional vein of fantasy, but they have their share of magic and adventure, and I highly recommend them.